Oscar Blog

« 'Juno,' Dano gain traction at | Main | Lionsgate gets creative with t... »

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

Prognosticators' consensus?

I thought I'd waste a few brain cells this morning and dig through all these prognosticative charts to see what the consensus is amongst those of us crazy enough to go on the record with predictions months out from the Oscar ceremony.

For those unaware, there is the Buzzmeter at The Envelope, a group comprised of 21 critics, columnists and awards analysts; the Gurus o' Gold at Movie City News, a smaller group of 14 similar types (with some Buzzmeter overlap); Gurus 2.0, also at Movie City News, a collective of 15 self-starting webmasters and contributors from some other sanctioned outlets not typically considered for their Oscar coverage; and newly formed, the Sultans of Bling at Awards Daily, a unique group comprised of 22 "civilians," if you will, individuals without outlets or platforms beyond comments sections in this site or that (save AW contributors Ryan C. Adams and Sasha Stone).

If you're not tongue-tied yet, I'll continue.

Three of the groups use a ranking system of 10 for their panelists.  A #1 choice gets a score of 10, a #2 a score of 9, etc.  The only group that uses a five-list system is the Buzzmeter, which obviously gives that collective less opportunity to add other titles to the ring beyond their respective top fives.  One might expect, therefore, a lesser amount of films to be represented by the Buzzmeter.  They list 16, but the Gurus o' Gold list a total of 17 films, with each panelist having the opportunity to list up to ten films.  But to be fair, the Buzzmeter also has seven extra members, so it's kind of a give and take.

I tallied up the scores from each of the films predicted for Best Picture today and came to some interesting findings.  First and foremost, "Into the Wild" gets a huge boost (landing in the #6 spot) by being a clear favorite for two groups, Gurus 2.0 and the Sultans.  The main Gurus and the Buzzmeter, however, have the film listed at #12 and #10 respectively.

Many films, of course, are listed across all four groups, but the Sultans, for instance, are the only group to include "The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford," "Beowulf," "Control," "The Golden Compass," "I'm Not There," "Lars and the Real Girl," "Ratatouille," "Rescue Dawn" and "We Own the Night."  Of those nine, I don't think it is out of bounds to say at least six have no shot at Best Picture contention, but the unique flavor is certainly welcome.

The Sultans, also, join Gurus 2.0 as the only groups to include "Zodiac" in their lists, while the latter is the only collective to feature "In the Valley of Elah" and "Things We Lost in the Fire."  The main Gurus group, meanwhile, is the only group to list "The Savages."

31 films are represented in total, while the Buzzmeter's 16 are the only ones shared across the board.

Now, let's get to the consensus chart.  Here's the full, ranked list of 31 films predicted for Best Picture by the four prognosticative groups out there on the Oscarweb:

01. "Atonement" (482)
02. "No Country for Old Men" (472)
03. "There Will Be Blood" (248)
04. "American Gangster "(231)
05. "The Kite Runner" (223)
06. "Into the Wild" (188)
07. "Charlie Wilson’s War" (173)
08. "Sweeney Todd" (170)
09. "Michael Clayton" (167)
10. "Juno" (144)
11. "Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead" (114)
12. "The Diving Bell and the Butterfly" (84)
13. "3:10 to Yuma"(56)
14. "Once" (47)
15. "Zodiac" (34)
16. "Eastern Promises" (16)
17. "Hairspray" (13)
18. "The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford" (12)
19. "In the Valley of Elah" (12)
20. "I’m Not There" (11)
21. "Ratatouille" (7)
22. "Rescue Dawn" (7)
23. "The Savages" (7)
24. "Elizabeth: The Golden Age" (6)
25. "Gone Baby Gone" (3)
26. "Control" (3)
27. "Things We Lost in the Fire" (2)
28. "The Golden Compass" (2)
29. "Lars and the Real Girl" (2)
30. "We Own the Night" (1)
31. "Beowulf" (1)
Obviously -- and as if this wasn't clear to begin with -- "Atonement" is the frontrunner for a nomination in this year's Best Picture race, if we're to go by what these collectives have to say.  This seems to have been the case ever since the Venice bow of the film back in September.

Meanwhile, "No Country for Old Men" and "There Will Be Blood" follow right behind, two films that, interestingly enough, are beginning to split some inside and outside of these groups regarding Oscar potential.

Universal's "American Gangster" has seemingly become the prognosticators' film of choice from that studio, while murmurs of "Charlie Wilson's War" being considered a comedy continue to cycle through, amongst other concerns.

"The Kite Runner," clearly an Oscar-bait contender, rounds it out in a list that I truly think will change substantially over the next couple of months.  We'll keep an eye out, but one thing is for sure -- we aren't short on Oscar predictions and opinions this season.

Comments

From a statistical perspective this is the smart play, Kris. If one assumes that those who have studied the Oscar awards process have some ability to predict its outcomes with accuracy (better than chance) then the more such individuals you have in your sample the greater the likely overall accuracy of prediction. The individual differences most responsible for error – personal favoritism, selective attention, quirky reasoning etc. – get better balanced out within a bigger sample. Look to the combined picks in the end to outperform any of the individual prognosticator groups.

Post a comment

Display Name

Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above:

About

About

Kristopher TapleyRed Carpet District is Variety contributor Kristopher Tapley's attempt at making sense of the ever-expanding glut of film awards coverage. He's been on the beat for six years. Email Kristopher Tapley

80th Academy Award Contenders

July 19 - TCA Awards
Sept 7 - MTV Video Music Awards, Paramount Studios
Sept 21 - Emmy Awards, Nokia Theater
'The Duchess'
Who is Ralph Fiennes? The shape-shifting actor is on course to have the most productive, and possibly most successful, year yet of an already illustrious career.
Ralph Fiennes' constant shape-shifting
Fiennes keeps theater door open
'Welcome Snoop'
A growing number of branded entertainment projects have paired up producers in Hollywood with the marketers on Madison Avenue to do one thing: use content to drive commerce.
Branded entertainment increases
One Show judges weigh choices
90210
When Fox launched the original "Beverly Hills, 90210" in 1990, fashion was not at the forefront.
'90210' graduates to higher fashion
'Women' share a common thread

Recent Comments

  • Ready-to-tankstop on 11/8 Oscarweb Round-up
  • Reoriaamori on 11/8 Oscarweb Round-up
  • Coakoffescess on 11/8 Oscarweb Round-up
  • Intuiniinsedy on 11/8 Oscarweb Round-up
  • fepestant on 11/8 Oscarweb Round-up
  • Categories

  • 3:10 to Yuma (10)
  • American Gangster (17)
  • Amy Adams (3)
  • Andrew Dominik (1)
  • Ang Lee (2)
  • Angelina Jolie (5)
  • Animation (20)
  • Atonement (50)
  • Australia (1)
  • Awards (8)
  • Away from Her (2)
  • Before the Devil Knows You're Dead (15)
  • Benicio Del Toro (1)
  • Beowulf (20)
  • Best Actor (64)
  • Best Actress (45)
  • Best Adapted Screenplay (27)
  • Best Animated Feature (22)
  • Best Art Direction (21)
  • Best Cinematography (27)
  • Best Costume Design (16)
  • Best Director (34)
  • Best Documentary Feature (15)
  • Best Film Editing (17)
  • Best Makeup (7)
  • Best Original Score (26)
  • Best Original Screenplay (18)
  • Best Original Song (19)
  • Best Sound Editing (17)
  • Best Sound Mixing (28)
  • Best Supporting Actor (37)
  • Best Supporting Actress (36)
  • Best Visual Effects (13)
  • Body of Lies (1)
  • Brad Pitt (2)
  • Bryan Singer (1)
  • Casey Affleck (13)
  • Cate Blanchett (13)
  • Charlie Wilson's War (30)
  • Chris McCandless (5)
  • Chris Weitz (1)
  • Christian Bale (3)
  • Christopher Nolan (5)
  • Coen Bros. (21)
  • Critics (7)
  • Critics Awards (25)
  • Daniel Craig (1)
  • Daniel Day-Lewis (28)
  • Defiance (2)
  • Denzel Washington (9)
  • DGA (11)
  • Diablo Cody (8)
  • Dreamworks SKG (1)
  • Eddie Vedder (12)
  • Edward Zwick (1)
  • Ellen Page (18)
  • Emile Hirsch (11)
  • Enchanted (6)
  • Eric Roth (1)
  • Festivals (6)
  • Film Awards News (23)
  • Focus Features (3)
  • Fox Searchlight Pictures (4)
  • Francis Ford Coppola (1)
  • Frank Langella (4)
  • Frost/Nixon (2)
  • George Clooney (17)
  • Golden Globes (23)
  • Guerilla (2)
  • Guild Awards (22)
  • Guild Screenings (8)
  • Hairspray (11)
  • Hal Holbrook (12)
  • Heath Ledger (14)
  • Helena Bonham Carter (4)
  • HFPA (5)
  • Independent Spirit Awards (1)
  • Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (1)
  • Interviews (4)
  • Into the Wild (47)
  • Jack Nicholson (4)
  • James McAvoy (1)
  • Jason Bateman (1)
  • Jason Reitman (6)
  • Javier Bardem (12)
  • Jennifer Garner (2)
  • Joe Wright (3)
  • John C. Reilly (1)
  • Johnny Depp (10)
  • Jon Stewart (4)
  • Jonny Greenwood (6)
  • Josh Brolin (5)
  • Judd Apatow (3)
  • Julian Schnabel (11)
  • Julie Christie (3)
  • Juno (57)
  • Kate Winslet (1)
  • Keira Knightly (2)
  • Knocked Up (5)
  • La Vie en Rose (6)
  • Laura Linney (6)
  • Leonardo DiCaprio (1)
  • Lionsgate Films (1)
  • Lust, Caution (6)
  • Marion Cotillard (8)
  • Michael Clayton (42)
  • Miramax Films (7)
  • Morgan Freeman (1)
  • New Line Cinema (3)
  • News (21)
  • Nicole Kidman (1)
  • No Country for Old Men (97)
  • Oscar Events (19)
  • Oscar News (20)
  • Oscars (5)
  • Oscarweb (292)
  • Paramount Pictures (3)
  • Paramount Vantage Pictures (16)
  • PGA (4)
  • Phillip Seymour Hoffman (11)
  • Picturehouse Entertainment (1)
  • Predictions (4)
  • Press Screenings (6)
  • Ratatouille (19)
  • Revolutionary Road (2)
  • Ridley Scott (1)
  • Robert Zemeckis (2)
  • Ron Howard (1)
  • Russell Crowe (4)
  • SAG (14)
  • Saoirse Ronan (4)
  • Sean Penn (8)
  • Shia LaBeouf (1)
  • Sidney Lumet (5)
  • Sony Pictures Classics (1)
  • Starting Out in the Evening (1)
  • Steven Spielberg (1)
  • Sweeney Todd (57)
  • Tang Wei (2)
  • Technical Categories (12)
  • The Argentine (3)
  • The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (21)
  • The Bucket List (5)
  • The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (3)
  • The Dark Knight (9)
  • The Diving Bell and the Butterfly (38)
  • The Golden Compass (13)
  • The Great Debaters (17)
  • The Kite Runner (15)
  • The No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency (1)
  • The Reader (1)
  • The Savages (14)
  • The Weinstein Company (1)
  • There Will Be Blood (82)
  • Tim Burton (13)
  • Tom Cruise (1)
  • Tom Hanks (5)
  • Tom Wilkinson (6)
  • Tommy Lee Jones (4)
  • Tony Gilroy (11)
  • Universal Pictures (5)
  • Valkyrie (1)
  • Vanessa Redgrave (1)
  • Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story (3)
  • Warner Bros. Pictures (11)
  • WGA (14)
  • Youth Without Youth (1)
  • Zodiac (6)