Oscar Blog

« 1/23 Oscarweb Round-up | Main | Sound mixer hopes to put an Os... »

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Goldstein chimes in, keeps his blog-hating puppy on a leash

Taking a break from Oscar blogger bashing yesterday, Patrick Goldtein of the Los Angeles Times pondered the peculiarities of this year's Oscar line-up.  He sees the 2007 as further evidence of a paradigm shift away from the status quo of Hollywood dollars and the continued enbracing of maverick visions.

He starts out like so:

When I took a bleary-eyed glance at the nomination results early yesterday morning, I have to admit that my first reaction was -- is this the Oscars or the Independent Spirit Awards?

Four of the five nominees for best picture are films released by studio specialty divisions, which largely focus on movies with a limited commercial reach. The fifth film, "Michael Clayton," was released by Warner Bros. but financed by Steve Samuels, a real estate developer from Boston who bankrolled the project when no studio would put up the money.


And later, he really digs in:

Most telling of all, the best picture nominees are not films that could have endured the "Survivor"-like experience of receiving notes from today's studio executives, cautious overseers obsessed with establishing character motivation and ensuring that the audience is never confused or particularly challenged. I won't give away any spoilers, but both "No Country for Old Men" and Anderson's' "There Will Be Blood" have striking endings that have confounded or even outraged viewers, but they've remained intact, since when you throw your lot in with these guys, if you're in for a dime, you're in for a dollar.

One can only imagine what would've happened to any of these nominees if they'd been forced to run the gauntlet of research screenings, with "No Country's" unflinching lack of emotion, "There Will Be Blood's" baldly unsympathetic lead character, "Atonement's" fractured flashback-and-forward narrative, "Michael Clayton's" elusive storytelling and "Juno's" casual acceptance of a 16-year-old girl's unplanned pregnancy. Although distributed by Fox Searchlight, "Juno" was independently financed by Mandate Pictures, which specializes in low-budget art-house and horror movies. If the film had been at a major studio it wouldn't be a stretch to hear a studio executive saying to Diablo Cody, who wrote the script, "I really love the cool slang and the funny phone, but does Juno really have to be pregnant?"


Read the rest.

About

About

Kristopher TapleyRed Carpet District is Variety contributor Kristopher Tapley's attempt at making sense of the ever-expanding glut of film awards coverage. He's been on the beat for six years. Email Kristopher Tapley

80th Academy Award Contenders

July 19 - TCA Awards
Sept 7 - MTV Video Music Awards, Paramount Studios
Sept 21 - Emmy Awards, Nokia Theater
Imagen Awards
This year, the Imagen Foundation doles out its awards with even more gusto than in the past.
Latinos making progress in Hollywood
Writer hits universal themes
Road to the Emmys: Down to the Wire
After years of rotating among the four broadcast networks, could it finally be time for the Emmy "wheel" to plot a new course?
Cable could make play for Emmycast
Do Emmy noms boost cable ratings?
Road to the Emmys: The Writer & The Producer
Compare a recent episode of NBC's "30 Rock" to the pilot episode, and it almost seems like a different show. Do that in front of "30 Rock" creator-exec producer Tina Fey, and she's likely to cringe.
Top TV shows rip up old blueprint
TV writers rigorous about research

Recent Comments

  • tima on 'Juno' Jargon
  • Nex on Oscars 2009???
  • SonespeassE on 11/8 Oscarweb Round-up
  • Poepannaffify on 11/8 Oscarweb Round-up
  • Cassie Layne on Oscars 2009???
  • Categories

  • 3:10 to Yuma (10)
  • American Gangster (17)
  • Amy Adams (3)
  • Andrew Dominik (1)
  • Ang Lee (2)
  • Angelina Jolie (5)
  • Animation (20)
  • Atonement (50)
  • Australia (1)
  • Awards (8)
  • Away from Her (2)
  • Before the Devil Knows You're Dead (15)
  • Benicio Del Toro (1)
  • Beowulf (20)
  • Best Actor (64)
  • Best Actress (45)
  • Best Adapted Screenplay (27)
  • Best Animated Feature (22)
  • Best Art Direction (21)
  • Best Cinematography (27)
  • Best Costume Design (16)
  • Best Director (34)
  • Best Documentary Feature (15)
  • Best Film Editing (17)
  • Best Makeup (7)
  • Best Original Score (26)
  • Best Original Screenplay (18)
  • Best Original Song (19)
  • Best Sound Editing (17)
  • Best Sound Mixing (28)
  • Best Supporting Actor (37)
  • Best Supporting Actress (36)
  • Best Visual Effects (13)
  • Body of Lies (1)
  • Brad Pitt (2)
  • Bryan Singer (1)
  • Casey Affleck (13)
  • Cate Blanchett (13)
  • Charlie Wilson's War (30)
  • Chris McCandless (5)
  • Chris Weitz (1)
  • Christian Bale (3)
  • Christopher Nolan (5)
  • Coen Bros. (21)
  • Critics (7)
  • Critics Awards (25)
  • Daniel Craig (1)
  • Daniel Day-Lewis (28)
  • Defiance (2)
  • Denzel Washington (9)
  • DGA (11)
  • Diablo Cody (8)
  • Dreamworks SKG (1)
  • Eddie Vedder (12)
  • Edward Zwick (1)
  • Ellen Page (18)
  • Emile Hirsch (11)
  • Enchanted (6)
  • Eric Roth (1)
  • Festivals (6)
  • Film Awards News (23)
  • Focus Features (3)
  • Fox Searchlight Pictures (4)
  • Francis Ford Coppola (1)
  • Frank Langella (4)
  • Frost/Nixon (2)
  • George Clooney (17)
  • Golden Globes (23)
  • Guerilla (2)
  • Guild Awards (22)
  • Guild Screenings (8)
  • Hairspray (11)
  • Hal Holbrook (12)
  • Heath Ledger (14)
  • Helena Bonham Carter (4)
  • HFPA (5)
  • Independent Spirit Awards (1)
  • Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (1)
  • Interviews (4)
  • Into the Wild (47)
  • Jack Nicholson (4)
  • James McAvoy (1)
  • Jason Bateman (1)
  • Jason Reitman (6)
  • Javier Bardem (12)
  • Jennifer Garner (2)
  • Joe Wright (3)
  • John C. Reilly (1)
  • Johnny Depp (10)
  • Jon Stewart (4)
  • Jonny Greenwood (6)
  • Josh Brolin (5)
  • Judd Apatow (3)
  • Julian Schnabel (11)
  • Julie Christie (3)
  • Juno (57)
  • Kate Winslet (1)
  • Keira Knightly (2)
  • Knocked Up (5)
  • La Vie en Rose (6)
  • Laura Linney (6)
  • Leonardo DiCaprio (1)
  • Lionsgate Films (1)
  • Lust, Caution (6)
  • Marion Cotillard (8)
  • Michael Clayton (42)
  • Miramax Films (7)
  • Morgan Freeman (1)
  • New Line Cinema (3)
  • News (21)
  • Nicole Kidman (1)
  • No Country for Old Men (97)
  • Oscar Events (19)
  • Oscar News (20)
  • Oscars (5)
  • Oscarweb (292)
  • Paramount Pictures (3)
  • Paramount Vantage Pictures (16)
  • PGA (4)
  • Phillip Seymour Hoffman (11)
  • Picturehouse Entertainment (1)
  • Predictions (4)
  • Press Screenings (6)
  • Ratatouille (19)
  • Revolutionary Road (2)
  • Ridley Scott (1)
  • Robert Zemeckis (2)
  • Ron Howard (1)
  • Russell Crowe (4)
  • SAG (14)
  • Saoirse Ronan (4)
  • Sean Penn (8)
  • Shia LaBeouf (1)
  • Sidney Lumet (5)
  • Sony Pictures Classics (1)
  • Starting Out in the Evening (1)
  • Steven Spielberg (1)
  • Sweeney Todd (57)
  • Tang Wei (2)
  • Technical Categories (12)
  • The Argentine (3)
  • The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (21)
  • The Bucket List (5)
  • The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (3)
  • The Dark Knight (9)
  • The Diving Bell and the Butterfly (38)
  • The Golden Compass (13)
  • The Great Debaters (17)
  • The Kite Runner (15)
  • The No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency (1)
  • The Reader (1)
  • The Savages (14)
  • The Weinstein Company (1)
  • There Will Be Blood (82)
  • Tim Burton (13)
  • Tom Cruise (1)
  • Tom Hanks (5)
  • Tom Wilkinson (6)
  • Tommy Lee Jones (4)
  • Tony Gilroy (11)
  • Universal Pictures (5)
  • Valkyrie (1)
  • Vanessa Redgrave (1)
  • Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story (3)
  • Warner Bros. Pictures (11)
  • WGA (14)
  • Youth Without Youth (1)
  • Zodiac (6)