Oscar Blog

« 34 nods and counting... | Main | THE NOMINEES: 'Persepolis'... »

Friday, February 1, 2008

Oscar's changing face

Christy Lemire of the Associated Press wrote up a story last week about the combined "unpopular" nature of this year's Best Picture hopefuls, and I have to say, more than a few points rang a bit false to me.  I get frustrated when journalists attempt to consolidate what an Oscar season is into tiny, bite-size, consumable ideas.  I also become frustrated when such ideas are in fact apparent, but become a little skewed in the reporting.

Let me just indicate a few examples from the piece:

Oscar-nominated films are often small, dark and unintended for mass audiences; they're about art, after all, not commerce. But that's especially true of this year's crop, which has little mainstream buzz and among the lowest box-office totals in recent years.

Not exactly.  The Academy is quite famous for erring on the side of popularity, though the group has slowly shifted its perspective of "populaity" from mass appeal to critical approval, for whatever reason.  The same pressure to give the biggest grossing film of all time the Best Pic laurels over the critical consensus in 1997 has manifested itself in the Academy's apparently conscious decison to recognize films somewhat out of its typically safe wheelhouse due to critical insistence ("No Country for Old Men," "There Will Be Blood").

But even still, the notion that "Oscar-nominated films are often small" and "dark" is a stretch to anyone who has paid attention long enough.  There is a reason films like "Atonement," "The Aviator," "Seabiscuit," etc. are consistently considered Oscar favorites from afar.  The Academy likes broad acceptability, and that doesn't necessarily indicate "small" and "dark" to me.  But, admittedly, things have been slowly changing for at least three or four years now.

Moving on...

Four of the movies nominated last week for best picture — "Juno," "Michael Clayton," "No Country for Old Men" and "There Will Be Blood" — got the so-called "Oscar bump" that comes from audiences checking them out the following weekend. (The sweeping romance "Atonement" dropped slightly.)

Still, they've only combined to make about $246.3 million domestically. In contrast, "The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King" already had grossed about $364 million all by itself by the time it won best picture in 2004.

This isn't the best of points because "The Return of the King" was a phenomenon, and the end result of a three-part series destined for Oscar glory in its denouement.  It is just also one example from 3 years ago.  The box office scenario has slowly been fleeing from the vogue scene where Oscar is concerned, witness by last year's relatively modest monetary crop and especially 2005's, which has been considered one of the most unpopular line-ups ever (and, indeed, saw the Oscar telecast's lowest viewership of all time).

I think the better point for a piece like this to make is the steady march to where we are now, rather than trying to posit the class of 2007 as any sort of major bellwether.  But I don't want to go through Lemire's piece with a comb or anything.  It is valuable to note how incredibly low-key the year's contenders are, and even how relatively dark and "70s" the consensus possibility is ("Michael Clayton").

Also, the only demographically "classic" Best Picture nominees from the past few years have been "The Aviator," "Ray" and "Atonement."  Two of them came in 2004 and I don't think one could make similar arguments for the likes of "Crash" or "Munich" or "Babel."  The idea of what an "oscar movie" is seems to be changing at the same time, which is interesting.  In five or six years, a new "sort" will be consistently considered a contender from afar (how about that alliteration?).  And then, the cycle will likely start all over again.

Interesting, no?  Check out Lemire's AP story.

Post a comment

Display Name

Change Image
Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above.
Note the letters are NOT case sensitive.

About

About

Kristopher TapleyRed Carpet District is Variety contributor Kristopher Tapley's attempt at making sense of the ever-expanding glut of film awards coverage. He's been on the beat for six years. Email Kristopher Tapley

80th Academy Award Contenders

Jan. 28 - AMPAS - final ballots mailed
Jan. 28 - MPSE - final ballots distributed
Jan. 30 - ASIFA Annie Awards
Jan. 30 - DGA - feature film final ballots due
Jan. 30 - VES - online viewing & voting begins
Jan. 31 - DGA Awards
'The Doctors'
Sit down at any dinner table in America and you know someone will start talking about health issues, even if it makes you squirm to hear about grandma's latest ailment.
'Doctors' deliver daytime ratings
Daytime Emmys may have new home
Mickey Rourke
Award season is not only a love fest for stars, the red carpet also has become a match made in heaven for brands.
Marketers vie for Oscar night spotlight
The ultimate acceptance speech
Cate Blanchett
After more than two decades of honoring independent film, the rowdy Spirit Awards remain the other hot ticket of Oscar weekend.
Spirits Awards spotlight edgy fare
Coogan continues Spirit's irreverence

Recent Comments

  • student lingerie on Screen Actors Guild Awards
  • Loan Rate >> How can I refinance my cc . on Screen Actors Guild Awards
  • MilmeteNumMit on A milkshake just arrived at my doorstep...
  • High class London escorts on Jonny Greenwood's 'Blood' score disqualified by AMPAS
  • HixRhymnmix on 11/8 Oscarweb Round-up
  • Categories

  • 3:10 to Yuma (10)
  • American Gangster (17)
  • Amy Adams (3)
  • Andrew Dominik (1)
  • Ang Lee (2)
  • Angelina Jolie (5)
  • Animation (20)
  • Atonement (50)
  • Australia (1)
  • Awards (8)
  • Away from Her (2)
  • Before the Devil Knows You're Dead (15)
  • Benicio Del Toro (1)
  • Beowulf (20)
  • Best Actor (64)
  • Best Actress (45)
  • Best Adapted Screenplay (27)
  • Best Animated Feature (22)
  • Best Art Direction (21)
  • Best Cinematography (27)
  • Best Costume Design (16)
  • Best Director (34)
  • Best Documentary Feature (15)
  • Best Film Editing (17)
  • Best Makeup (7)
  • Best Original Score (26)
  • Best Original Screenplay (18)
  • Best Original Song (19)
  • Best Sound Editing (17)
  • Best Sound Mixing (28)
  • Best Supporting Actor (37)
  • Best Supporting Actress (36)
  • Best Visual Effects (13)
  • Body of Lies (1)
  • Brad Pitt (2)
  • Bryan Singer (1)
  • Casey Affleck (13)
  • Cate Blanchett (13)
  • Charlie Wilson's War (30)
  • Chris McCandless (5)
  • Chris Weitz (1)
  • Christian Bale (3)
  • Christopher Nolan (5)
  • Coen Bros. (21)
  • Critics (7)
  • Critics Awards (25)
  • Daniel Craig (1)
  • Daniel Day-Lewis (28)
  • Defiance (2)
  • Denzel Washington (9)
  • DGA (11)
  • Diablo Cody (8)
  • Dreamworks SKG (1)
  • Eddie Vedder (12)
  • Edward Zwick (1)
  • Ellen Page (18)
  • Emile Hirsch (11)
  • Enchanted (6)
  • Eric Roth (1)
  • Festivals (6)
  • Film Awards News (23)
  • Focus Features (3)
  • Fox Searchlight Pictures (4)
  • Francis Ford Coppola (1)
  • Frank Langella (4)
  • Frost/Nixon (2)
  • George Clooney (17)
  • Golden Globes (23)
  • Guerilla (2)
  • Guild Awards (22)
  • Guild Screenings (8)
  • Hairspray (11)
  • Hal Holbrook (12)
  • Heath Ledger (14)
  • Helena Bonham Carter (4)
  • HFPA (5)
  • Independent Spirit Awards (1)
  • Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (1)
  • Interviews (4)
  • Into the Wild (47)
  • Jack Nicholson (4)
  • James McAvoy (1)
  • Jason Bateman (1)
  • Jason Reitman (6)
  • Javier Bardem (12)
  • Jennifer Garner (2)
  • Joe Wright (3)
  • John C. Reilly (1)
  • Johnny Depp (10)
  • Jon Stewart (4)
  • Jonny Greenwood (6)
  • Josh Brolin (5)
  • Judd Apatow (3)
  • Julian Schnabel (11)
  • Julie Christie (3)
  • Juno (57)
  • Kate Winslet (1)
  • Keira Knightly (2)
  • Knocked Up (5)
  • La Vie en Rose (6)
  • Laura Linney (6)
  • Leonardo DiCaprio (1)
  • Lionsgate Films (1)
  • Lust, Caution (6)
  • Marion Cotillard (8)
  • Michael Clayton (42)
  • Miramax Films (7)
  • Morgan Freeman (1)
  • New Line Cinema (3)
  • News (21)
  • Nicole Kidman (1)
  • No Country for Old Men (97)
  • Oscar Events (19)
  • Oscar News (20)
  • Oscars (5)
  • Oscarweb (292)
  • Paramount Pictures (3)
  • Paramount Vantage Pictures (16)
  • PGA (4)
  • Phillip Seymour Hoffman (11)
  • Picturehouse Entertainment (1)
  • Predictions (4)
  • Press Screenings (6)
  • Ratatouille (19)
  • Revolutionary Road (2)
  • Ridley Scott (1)
  • Robert Zemeckis (2)
  • Ron Howard (1)
  • Russell Crowe (4)
  • SAG (14)
  • Saoirse Ronan (4)
  • Sean Penn (8)
  • Shia LaBeouf (1)
  • Sidney Lumet (5)
  • Sony Pictures Classics (1)
  • Starting Out in the Evening (1)
  • Steven Spielberg (1)
  • Sweeney Todd (57)
  • Tang Wei (2)
  • Technical Categories (12)
  • The Argentine (3)
  • The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (21)
  • The Bucket List (5)
  • The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (3)
  • The Dark Knight (9)
  • The Diving Bell and the Butterfly (38)
  • The Golden Compass (13)
  • The Great Debaters (17)
  • The Kite Runner (15)
  • The No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency (1)
  • The Reader (1)
  • The Savages (14)
  • The Weinstein Company (1)
  • There Will Be Blood (82)
  • Tim Burton (13)
  • Tom Cruise (1)
  • Tom Hanks (5)
  • Tom Wilkinson (6)
  • Tommy Lee Jones (4)
  • Tony Gilroy (11)
  • Universal Pictures (5)
  • Valkyrie (1)
  • Vanessa Redgrave (1)
  • Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story (3)
  • Warner Bros. Pictures (11)
  • WGA (14)
  • Youth Without Youth (1)
  • Zodiac (6)