The only thing moderately surprising about
today's WGA nominations is the inclusion of "Zodiac" in the field of adapted scripts. Sure, the James Vanderbuilt adaptation of the Robert Graysmith novel received a nomination for the USC Scripter prize, but I felt that might have been more attributed to Graysmith than the actual script itself, which really has no structure to speak of and wouldn't seem the "typical" choice for this guild. But, in any case, this reveals that industry support is indeed there.
The presence of "Knocked Up" in the original ranks should come as a shock to no one. Judd Apatow was cited for his work two years ago on "The 40 Year Old Virgin" by the guild. I don't expect this to translate to Oscar, however, given the WGA's penchant for recognizing comedies that AMPAS is fine with ignoring ("Stranger Than Fiction," "Thank You for Smoking," "Garden State," "Mean Girls,""Bend It Like Beckham," "The Station Agent," "Best in Show," "High Fidelity," the list goes on and on).
Otherwise, it was buisness as usual. "Into the Wild" and "No Country for Old Men" remain the standouts during the precursor season that matters, as "There Will Be Blood" continues to make a case for itself as a Best Picture contender. That, frankly, is shocking to me. And the potential is all too possible for Scott Rudin to be his own worst enemy this season, because if both "No Country" and "Blood" make Oscar's final five, I could tell you a day-long story about how they will cancel each other out in the voting process. Which means things ought to be looking even better for "Wild" -- but that's a whole other conversation.
"The Diving Bell and the Butterfly" is also still in the thick of the year's competition, grabbing two makjor guild mentions this week, while "Atonement" has officially sunk like the heaviest stone one could have imagined. At this point, the only hope for Joe Wright's film is the entire BAFTA/AMPAS crossover contingent to stick it in the #1 spot on their ballots. Then, and only then, does it seem to have a prayer of finding a Best Picture nomination.
Ah, the malleability of an Oscar season.