News

Posted: Mon., Aug. 11, 2008, 2:20pm PT

Lawyer, cops vie for kudo credibility

Film stars bring new blood to tight race

Lead Actress Drama nominees

Lead Actress Drama Nominees (starting from the top): Glenn Close, Sally Field, Mariska Hargitay, Holly Hunter and Kyra Sedgwick.

Strong, complicated women are at the heart of this category, and each possesses undeniable maturity and wisdom. Three of the characters are cops, but each character is strikingly different, due in part to the actresses playing them.

Holly Hunter earned her nomination for "Saving Grace," her first foray into episodic television. She plays a detective who encounters a guardian angel, and the two often differ on how Hunter's character should live her life, but the banter between the two -- and the way she leads her life -- helps the show rise from strict procedural.

Kyra Sedgwick and Mariska Hargitay each have multiple nominations for playing detectives as well. Sedgwick's detective on TNT's "The Closer" is a Southern belle with bite, while Hargitay -- who won in 2006 -- continues to bring a street-smart sense in dealing with degenerates on NBC's "Law & Order: SVU."

After her nomination for FX's "The Shield," Glenn Close's recognition for "Damages" seems like a natural progression. Pleasant one second and vicious the next, Close brings an icy warmth to the high-powered attorney and master manipulator who constantly confused her own employees of her true agenda. Close always chooses strong roles, but few have been as complex as this one.

While last year's winner, Sally Field, doesn't play a lawyer, cop or high-powered professional, she's turned her character on "Brothers & Sisters" into a tiny tower of strength to her children and grandchildren.

GLENN CLOSE

Show: "Damages"

Emmy pedigree: One win plus nine other noms

Best scene: Close, after trying to broker a deal with opposing attorney Zeljko Ivanek, looks ashen after he commits suicide in her office. She begins to internally contemplate what part she has played in his death.

Why she might win: Close offers an engaging portrayal of a driven woman for whom the ends justify the means. Her manipulative ways make for addictive viewing.

Maybe not: While it's the first time Close is nominated for "Damages," her one-for-10 batting average with the Emmys isn't encouraging.

SALLY FIELD

Show: "Brothers & Sisters"

Emmy pedigree: Three wins plus four other noms

Best scene: When Justin (David Annable), a recovering addict, refuses to take pain medication following a severe, war-related leg injury, Nora faces a mother's worst dilemma: watching her child suffer while knowing the pain can be alleviated.

Why she might win: No sappy grandma, Field has turned Nora from just one of the show's many characters into the linchpin of the series.

Maybe not: Having won last year for the role, it may be difficult to repeat against such stellar competish.

MARISKA HARGITAY

Show: "Law & Order: SVU"

Emmy pedigree: One win plus three other noms

Best scene: Hargitay's Det. Benson poses as an inmate to smoke out an official who's been raping women at the prison, including a girl who was visiting her mother.

Why she might win: Many of Hargitay's storylines have quite an emotional pull, rather than rote police work, and those pulling of heartstrings could make a difference.

Maybe not: The only nominee here not to have nearly the bigscreen cred as the others; if voters go for the wow factor, she might be up against it.

HOLLY HUNTER

Show: "Saving Grace"

Emmy pedigree: Two wins plus three other noms

Best scene: After decades of silence and burying the truth, Grace tells her best friend the details of her childhood sexual abuse at the hands of their priest. The scene offers insights as to why Grace is so distant, promiscuous, self-destructive and bitter when it comes to the church.

Why she might win: Hunter brings a raw energy to Grace, offering up flashes of the broken child beneath Grace's tough exterior. It's a difficult balance that she pulls off well.

Maybe not: Grace's coarseness and unbridled lifestyle may prove a bit off-putting to some older voters.

KYRA SEDGWICK

Show: "The Closer"

Emmy pedigree: Two noms

Best scene: Deputy Chief Brenda Johnson investigates the abduction of an 8-year-old girl but makes no headway with the prime suspect. Once she leaves, Sgt. Gabriel gets the suspect to talk after beating him, leaving Brenda shocked that he would jeopardize the case by committing a criminal act. Her disappointment in Gabriel was palpable and lasting.

Why she might win: Ratings for "The Closer" have been stellar, and voters might want to acknowledge the show's popularity by marking their ballots for Sedgwick.

Maybe not: There are other cops here -- Hunter and Hargitay also play detectives -- and it might be difficult for voters to distinguish Sedgwick's work from them.


TALKBACK:

Have an opinion about this article? Be the first to comment



Print Variety
Bookmark
Get Variety:
Variety Mobile Variety Digital Variety Home Delivery
Newsletter Signup:

Featured Jobs

Variety Real Estate