Oscar's no-shows


More News
Sam Mendes, the Oscar-winning director of 1999 best pic "American Beauty," his debut feature, has been less successful with subsequent efforts, including "Jarhead," the Desert Storm saga that seemed tailor-made to capitalize on a ripe year for topical films but which was sunk by the critics. The N.Y. Times said "Jarhead" "walks up to some of the most urgent and painful issues of our present circumstance, clears its throat loudly, and says nothing."

* * *

Ridley Scott, the master stylist and orchestrator of the thinking man's epic ("Gladiator") tackled the Crusades with "Kingdom of Heaven," even drawing parallels to the current Middle East conflict. But alas, Orlando Bloom is no Russell Crowe, and the film failed to live up to critical and commercial expectations. Entertainment Weekly's Owen Gleiberman called it "a handsome but curiously remote Crusades epic."

* * *

Cameron Crowe, of "Jerry Maguire" and "Almost Famous," which racked up nine Oscar noms between them, including a screenplay win for Crowe, paid more attention to "Elizabethtown's" soundtrack than its story and characters. The result was his worst-reviewed film since "Vanilla Sky," and a disappearing act in the theaters. "What in the world has happened to Cameron Crowe?" asked the New Yorker's David Denby.

* * *

Roman Polanksi, the director of "Chinatown" whose last film, 2002's "The Pianist, won him an Oscar, brought all of his maturity and personal orphan experience to bear in "Oliver Twist." But despite affecting performances and topnotch production values, the Sept. 23 release got lost in a blizzard of late-year entries and was written off by indifferent critics. "Lacks dramatic urgency and intriguing undercurrents," wrote Variety's Todd McCarthy.

* * *

When Rob Marshall, the frosh director of 2002 best pic "Chicago," was handed the "Memoirs of a Geisha" reins from Steven Spielberg, some viewed it as a symbolic passing of the torch from one wunderkind to another. But despite eye-popping visuals and stars Ziyi Zhang and Gong Li, "Memoirs" suffered some of the year's cattiest reviews. "Designing a movie isn't the same as directing one," wrote Robert Denerstein of the Denver Rocky Mountain news.

* * *

Curtis Hanson, whose 1997 "L.A. Confidential" collected nine Acad noms but was steamrolled at the Oscars by "Titanic," has been a critics' fave since, but his "In Her Shoes," despite decent r eviews, appeared lightweight and formulaic compared with past efforts like "Woner Boys" and "8 Mile." "Treats love like a pretty accessory to be stored in a plastic box and shoved in the back of a closet when it proves impractical," wote the L.A. Times.
 

Back to top