Celebrating 100 years of Variety




View articles from Variety Legend: Army Archerd



1960: Paging Dr. Kaye
A look back at the actor's antics

1960: Labor issues heat up Hollywood
A look back at past labor disputes

1960: Sinatra on politics
From the Army Archerd Archive

1960: MacLaine talks 'My Geisha'
Hope film will ease East-West understanding

1960: Update on 'King of Kings'
Filming schedule, issues arise on set

1960: Zimbalist loaned out for 'Love'
Army Archerd Archive

1960: 'Summer' finds a Hart
'Boys' actress jumps to new projects

1960: Hollywood enters political battle
Tinseltown biggies pick a side for election

1960: Sahl considered for 'Prince'
Politics plays part in Hollywood scene

1968: Welch gets cozy with co-star
Actress reflects on making of '100 Rifles'

1968: 'Julia' merry for 'Christmas'
Hit show plans special holiday episode

1968: Grant surprises Rickles
Hollywood honors Sultan of Insult

1968: Angie lays down the law
A look back at the career of Angie Dickinson

1968: Campbell warms to 'Norwood'
Crooner preps for post-'True Grit' pic

1968: Kirk Douglas talks politics
Outspoken actor chats on primaries

1968: Vaughn builds 'Bridge' to Prague
Actor recalls aftermath of RFK assassination

1968: CBS censors Smothers Bros.
A look back at the Dem convention

1968: Fess Parker plans a return
From The Army Archerd Archive

1968: Don Murray talks 'Outcasts'
Social issues take part in decision

1956: A walk in the park for Disney
Theme park bows 'Tom Sawyer's Island'


Payola, quiz scandals crossed wires in '59

By ELIZABETH GUIDER, Sun., Jul. 31, 2005, 6:00am PT



Sony and BMG got their wrists slapped and a $10 million fine last week in a widening radio payola probe.

But such scandals have dogged the radio and TV biz for years, and probably never more so than at the end of 1959, when apparently no one could talk, or write, about anything else.

Congress and the FCC got caught up, as did J. Edgar Hoover's G-men.

Many a talent -- from rock 'n' roll legend Alan Freed and "American Bandstand" producer Dick Clark to gameshow producer Dan Enright and contestant Charles van Doren -- were taken down or chastized.

TV and radio were forever changed: Quiz shows disappeared for decades; networks took more control of the creative process; ties between record companies and disc jockeys were severed or rearranged -- though as the current probe by New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer makes clear, payoffs, via indie promoters and others, have again become pervasive.

Variety's coverage of the '50s fiasco was extensive.

At first, elements of the misconduct came in dribs and drabs: A small page-one item in Daily Variety in March 1957 noted van Doren had been unseated on NBC quiz show "Twenty One" when he was stumped by a question about the king of Belgium. "Van Doren Muffs '21' Pitch After 14 Weeks" -- a seemingly innocuous piece.

By the following August, however, contestant Herb Stempel had admitted he pocketed $50,000 in winnings by having answers supplied to him -- and then took a dive so that van Doren could win. Back when events were unfolding, Daily Variety pointed out that there was "no obvious law against fixing a quiz show" unless it could be shown the sponsor had been defrauded by a conspiracy of network or ad agency personnel and contestants. But that impossible-to-prove technicality did not keep the floodgates from opening.

On Nov. 3, Daily Variety reported on its front page, "Van Doren Sings and Tunes; Is Hearts and Flowers in D.C."

The lead was to the point: "Charles van Doren today said he sinned and is sorry."

A congressional subcommittee also probed a Tennessee minister named Storey Jackson, who won $20,000 on "The $64,000 Question." He admitted that producer Shirley Bernstein (sister of Leonard) always had an advance "prep" session with him.

The scandals had repercussions -- monetary as well as moral ones.

The paper reported a week later that Hoover's G-men also would be looking into whether any of the contestants had communist ties.

Though not a direct result of the payola scandal, threats of censorship became more urgent, not just against the film biz but against radio, television, books, magazines and newspapers. The payola mess mushroomed into an indictment of the entire entertainment biz.

In the Nov. 11, 1959, issue of Daily Variety, four of eight front-page stories dealt with the scandal.

A piece headlined "Double-Pronged Probe Into Payola Slows Charge of the Loot Brigade," described how the boys in the music biz had started to run for cover.

In November, Variety editor George Rosen penned a thoughtful front-page banner called "Broadcasters Strike Back," in which he described how the TV biz was finally mobilizing to stem the smear on the medium.

"Unless something drastic is done, the publishers of dailies and magazines will stop at nothing to perpetuate the present quiz-rigging scandal and keep it a running story for years to come, no matter how flimsy the evidence."

The story went on to point out that in many key cities publishers actually own local stations, but that they had failed to pull the plug on any questionable (but profitable) show.

"Just as their radio holdings saved them from red ink (in the '30s and '40s), today they are using TV as a hedge -- against the day when they may have to look to their stations to meet publishing deficits."


Copyright 2008, Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Website is subject to Terms of Use. Privacy Policy