SAG's elective surgery stuns Hollywood
Savage, panel unanimously overturn November vote
In a wild week even by SAG's standards, the guild's elections committee first astounded Hollywood on Jan. 7 by setting aside Melissa Gilbert's Nov. 2 victory as president, along with wins by Elliott Gould for secretary and Kent McCord for treasurer.
The five-member committee, headed by Fred Savage, set a rerun and blasted SAG staff and Sequoia Voting Systems, which conducted the election.
In stinging language, the elections committee singled out deputy national exec director John Sucke, national director of guild governance Clinta Dayton and New York branch exec secretary Ruth Baptiste for bungling the election process. And it found the misconduct may have affected the outcome.
"We have a serious concern about the short-term and long-term integrity of SAG's election process," the panel wrote. "The committee has unanimously concluded that the manner in which the election of the three top officers was conducted falls far short of measuring up to the standards of a fair and level playing field, which is the cornerstone of the democratic process our members and candidates are entitled to receive."
Then, in an incident that summarized SAG's bitter internal feuding, guild staff threw gasoline on the fire by claiming Gilbert, Gould and McCord should remain in their slots until the rerunning of the election is concluded April 10. The reasons: "To avoid the undesirable consequence of a void in leadership" and the need to be "consistent" with federal law, even though the election had been invalidated.
When Gilbert opened a National Executive Committee meeting the next day, several committee members asserted she no longer had the authority to serve and suggested that 1st VP Mike Farrell or former president William Daniels be installed as acting president.
But SAG attorneys insisted the committee could not toss Gilbert, Gould and McCord out. That position perplexed and angered several elected leaders and candidates, most notably Eugene Boggs, who finished third in the presidential voting behind Gilbert (45%) and Valerie Harper (39%).
Boggs, a law professor who had already accused staff of showing a clear preference for Gilbert, insists SAG's attorneys have erred, since federal labor law only applies when a union does not resolve an election internally.
"SAG's election committee has reached a final decision, so this election is over and can't be challenged any longer," Boggs declared. "Melissa Gilbert cannot legally serve as president; her doing so is putting SAG in legal jeopardy for any actions it takes."
By the end of the week, Boggs had started to make good on his promise to try ousting Gilbert, Gould and McCord.
He brought up a motion to remove the trio at the Jan. 28 national board meeting, citing language in the SAG constitution providing two options: if the president's office is vacant, the 1st VP (Farrell) should be installed as acting president; or the national board can elect a president, secretary and treasurer to fill the vacancies for the balance of the term.
"The only way Melissa could legally become president before April 10 is if the national board decides to elect her at a meeting before then," he says.
Boggs, who has not decided if he will go through the rerun, offers the following scenario: If she remains in office, Gilbert will have a huge advantage during the upcoming campaign, which could lead to the rerun election also being invalidated, either by SAG or the Dept. of Labor.
For its part, after issuing the inflammatory ruling, SAG staff remained silent on all matters tied to the election, including whether Baptiste, Dayton and Sucke will be dismissed, as several members have urged.
